Now the officials who were watching suddenly realized. They finally understood why Zhang Fei used paintings to testify, why he made it so mysterious, and why he found so many witnesses to prove how the carriage broke into the shed.
In fact, he did so many things just to prove that the carriage rolled over into the shed because the right wheel got stuck in the ditch.
This was enough to win the case.
Su Shi, who had always been confident, couldn't help but feel a little bit frustrated.
If you let him come, he will definitely not fight like this. He advocates talking, but in this lawsuit, Zhang Fei relied entirely on evidence and did not argue too much.
"Teacher, how should we respond?"
Li Lei looked at Li Guozhong with a blank expression.
Having gone through hundreds of battles, he rarely showed such a bewildered expression in the hall.
Li Guozhong sighed: "Forget it! We have done our best."
Completely disarmed.
This is no longer a fight.
They used to think that they should be punished because there were no laws and regulations to specifically regulate the liability for traffic accidents caused by street intrusions.
However, there are clear regulations governing the determination of liability for traffic accidents caused by digging ditches and wells.
This intrusion into the street is illegal, but in the end, you changed the ditch route planned by the court without authorization, demolished the guardrail, and did not install any new ones.
The carriage did indeed roll over because its wheels got stuck in a ditch.
They had nothing left to fight back.
No matter how much you argue, you can't change this fact.
The old faces in the crowd were like eggplants beaten by frost.
It's completely wilted!
Last time Fan Chunren defeated Zhang Fei, was it... was it just an accident?
Since the opponent had no means of counterattack, they did not expect that Zhang Fei would do anything in this ditch, so they went directly to the closing speech.
Li Lei stood up first and said, "The street where the incident happened is in a busy city, and cars come and go every day. The ditch that the other party emphasized has existed for a long time, and it did not exist just a few days or months ago." Yes, but for two or three years.
And based on the testimonies of all eyewitnesses, we can clearly know that although there were occasional collisions at that street intersection, such a major accident had never happened.
Several witnesses just now believed that it was caused by the horse being frightened, because they heard the horse neighing, but based on this alone, they could not guarantee that it was not caused by improper driving.
At the same time, everyone should not ignore the fact that just before this, Patrolman Xie Hui had been busy for more than half a month and was exhausted physically and mentally.
Although this cannot be confirmed, whether it is a frightened horse or improper driving, our country has specific penalty standards. According to the laws of our country, even if the accident is caused by the horse, the horse owner should bear all the compensation for the loss, but the penalty can be reduced by two degrees.
In any case, Chunfeng Shili suffered huge losses due to this accident, which even reached the point of being unbearable.
The other party is still a patrol policeman. His duty is to maintain traffic. He should pay more attention to this aspect of safety than ordinary people and give people safety instead of fear. If the Director of Records determines that patrolman Xie Hui is exempt from liability, it may cause very bad consequences. As a result, police officers may become more unscrupulous.
Therefore, I implore the Department of Records to determine that Patrolman Xie Hui bears full responsibility and compensate for all losses suffered by Chunfeng Shili. "
After saying these words, Gu Ji and others, who had just been exhausted, suddenly cheered up again, and a glimmer of hope ignited in their hearts.
One side is the common people and the other side is the patrol police.
Once this issue becomes public, the government will have to worry about it.
After Li Lei sat down, Zhang Fei stood up, and everyone's eyes immediately focused on Zhang Fei.
And most people seemed very nervous.
In fact, they don't care about the compensation issue. It's not the first time they lost to Zhang Fei anyway. They care about whether Zhang Fei will aggravate the problem.
Focus on encroaching streets.
This is the key!
Zhang Fei glanced at them, as if he had seen through what they were thinking, raised the corner of his mouth slightly, and said with a relaxed expression, "I don't know if everyone present knows this, but Lu Siru must be very clear that at the beginning, the General Police Department has always been They all expressed their willingness to settle and pay reasonable compensation."
As he spoke, he looked at Lu Jia and asked.
Lu Jiawen nodded slightly, indicating that Zhang Fei was not lying.
Zhang Fei then continued: "At that time, some people speculated that the General Police Department believed that the responsibility was on its side, so it hoped to settle the matter and protect its own face, but this was not the case.
The reason why the General Police Department was willing to settle before was because the General Police Department believed that this traffic accident was entirely caused by Chunfeng Shili's street intrusion. "
He said the last half of the sentence very loudly and sonorously, as if he was afraid that everyone could not hear clearly.
The officials who were watching were all gnashing their teeth and looking fiercely.
I knew, I knew, that this kid wouldn't let us go so easily.
as expected.
Emphasize this from the beginning.
He then heard Zhang Fei say: "Then the question is, why has Chunfeng Shili continued to encroach on the streets in the past ten years, but the previous inspection department was indifferent to this?
This is the only reason why the General Police Department is willing to settle. Because the General Police Department believed that the Inspection Department was negligent in enforcing the law, which led to everything, and it must bear a certain responsibility. The Inspection Department has a close relationship with the General Police Department, and the General Police Department is willing to bear everything for the Inspection Department.
But I never expected that Dongfeng Shili was greedy. Not only did he not repent, he also demanded multiple times of compensation from the police station. I really don’t know who gave them the courage. "
Having said this, he looked directly at Gu Ji, you are the culprit.
Everyone's eyes also turned to Gu Ji.
Gu Ji suddenly panicked, and his hatred for Zhang Fei was unforgettable.
This is completely unnecessary, you just want to embarrass me!
Having said that, Zhang Fei, who was determined to retaliate, would never let him go.
Zhang Fei smiled slightly, looked down at the article again, and continued: "It is precisely because of the aggressive spring breeze that the General Police Department changed its view on this accident. The General Police Department believes that this kind of conniving behavior will actually make people angry. Chunfeng Shili has become more unscrupulous and greedy, so he decided to hire our Bianjing Law Firm to litigate. As for this lawsuit?"
Zhang Fei shrugged and smiled contemptuously: "There is no evidence to prove that patrolman Xie Hui committed any illegal behavior while driving, but the illegal ditch is there, and I don't think there is any dispute between it. .
By the way, I would like to say that what the other party said just now makes me feel very ridiculous. He seemed to be suggesting that the Secretary should wait until the next major accident occurs before determining whether the illegal ditch obstructs traffic. "
"I object."
Li Lei stood up immediately, "Zhang San's words are pure slander and have no basis."
"I take back what I just said, I'm done."
Zhang Fei quickly raised his hand to apologize, and then sat down.
"This brat." Wang Anshi shook his head with a smile, "Based on these last words alone, it is impossible for Si Lusi to judge Chunfeng Shili and the others as the winner!"
If we wait until the next accident to make a judgment, then Si Lusi will bear full responsibility.
This is so cruel.
Wen Yanbo stroked his beard and said, "Now it depends on what the Secretary Lu Division will decide."
Mr. Lu on the side was not as calm and calm as them at all, because he knew that Lu Jiawen would face great pressure when the lawsuit reached this point.
Sure enough, Lu Jiawen discussed with a group of managers and judicial detectives for a while, but did not give a verdict immediately. Instead, he chose to adjourn the court temporarily and went into the house to discuss with a group of judges.
But the officials present had already anticipated what they were arguing about.
The General Police Department must have won, and Chunfeng Shili must be held responsible, but the question is whether Si Lu Si will give an explanation for this intrusion into the street.
"Lu Silu, regarding the street intrusion, it is of great importance and involves many people. Even if it needs to be changed, the imperial court should issue an order. We do not have this power."
"If we decide that Chunfeng Shili's intrusion into the street is illegal and require it to rectify, it will cause great turmoil. I dare say that even Kaifeng Prefecture will not dare to judge easily."
"The best way is to determine that Chunfeng Shili bears full responsibility and compensate the General Police Department. As for whether to make rectifications, it should be left to the court to decide."
...
These experienced managers and judges knew the pros and cons, so they all persuaded Lu Jiawen not to get too involved in the street intrusion, but to limit the focus of the punishment to the division of responsibilities.
Lu Jiawen was young and energetic and a very thoughtful official. He just wanted this highlight moment. He had been looking forward to a classic case from the beginning.
If there is no street intrusion involved, it is purely an ordinary traffic accident.
Lu Jiawen nodded and said: "I know what everyone is worried about, but our judgment must be fair and just. The reason why the General Police Department is suing Chunfeng Shili now is Chunfeng Shili's street intrusion. If we decide that the General Police Department wins, and Ignoring this act of street intrusion is an imperfect judgment that will definitely be embarrassing. Maybe Zhang San will continue to appeal. He mentioned this point more than once in the lawsuit.
We do not have the right to judge that all street intrusions are illegal, but we have the right to demand that Chunfeng Shili make rectifications. If we do not make this request, who will bear the responsibility if another accident occurs in the future?
As for your worries, I think there is no need to worry about it at all, because it was them who brought the complaint, not us who took the initiative to punish them. Moreover, we also asked Chunfeng Shili to accept the conditions of the General Police Station, but Chunfeng Shili was unwilling. Now we can only judge based on the facts, and no one can blame us. "
The managers and judges looked at each other.
yes!
If you don't ask for rectification, if an accident happens next time, they will definitely be responsible for it.
In the final analysis, it was Chunfeng Shili who sought death on his own. If he had listened to his advice, nothing would have happened today.
If there's a problem, why should they wipe it?
If only the Chunfeng Shili family is judged to undergo rectification, it will not be very harmful. As for other street intrusions, it is still up to the court to decide.
After half an hour, Lu Jiawen returned to his seat with a group of managers and judges.
The officials' hearts jumped into their throats.
Lu Jiawen looked around and said loudly: "After our review, this traffic accident was entirely caused by Chunfeng Shili changing the ditch without authorization and not setting up warnings and guardrails. Therefore, I hereby declare that Chunfeng Shili will bear all the consequences." responsibility.
However, due to lack of sufficient evidence to support the claim of the General Police Department, Chunfeng Shili only had to compensate for the loss of carriages and horses, patrolman Xie Hui's medical expenses, and paint expenses, paying 87 yuan and 430 yuan. As for the reputational compensation, this has nothing to do with Chunfeng Shili, and Chunfeng Shili does not need to pay any compensation for this.
Since Chunfeng Shili's intrusion into the street has caused serious traffic hazards, I have ordered him to make rectifications immediately. During the rectification period, fences must be set up around the street. If any accidents occur during this period, I will severely punish you. . "
