The narrator said: Ye Yu, let me ask you a question, which one do you think is more important, procedural justice or result justice?
Ye Yu said: Why do you suddenly ask this question without any clue?
The narrator said: I watched "Assassination Storm" some time ago, and I was thinking, if the legal process allows the bad guys to escape punishment, is the law itself upholding justice, or is it harming justice? If it always harms justice, why does it represent justice? Just because those bad guys have money, they hire lawyers to help them study the law and find favorable evidence? So isn’t the law just justice for the rich?
Ye Yu said: You are a little confused.
The narrator said: How to say it?
Ye Yudao: To put it simply, procedural justice equals "doing things correctly", while consequential justice, also called substantive justice, actually equals "doing the right thing". So your first question is actually equivalent to asking: "Doing things correctly" or "Doing the right thing", which one is more important?
And your second problem is essentially that you are too idealistic. In your one-sided hope, law equals justice. But don’t forget that the law has always pursued justice. If the law is justice, why pursue it?
Of course, each of us hopes to "use the right means to do the right thing." In that case, the law can be equivalent to justice, but in fact this is not the case, because the law is not completely equal to justice, or in other words Legal justice is imperfect justice, it has flaws
Simply put, procedural justice and consequential justice conflict in some situations, and you can only choose one. At the same time, that defect is specifically reflected in the phenomenon mentioned in your second question.
Don't try to force changes, because if the law changes the process for you alone, it will achieve your personal justice. It seems that your justice has been served, but the price you pay for this law is that there will be hundreds of wealthy people who will take advantage of the loopholes in the "change" of the law to make thousands of people like you The rights of the weak are not protected.
Simply put, law is just the lesser of two powers that harm each other. This is where the law is imperfect. So you expect the law to be perfect, which is unrealistic in itself. Otherwise, why do you think we say "the law is the bottom line of human society" instead of the upper limit?
If there is a conflict between procedural justice and consequential justice, we can only give priority to procedural justice. Because you say that you insist on pursuing justice in the outcome, then the justice you can believe in in this world is the spirit of chivalry. Because the spirit of chivalry pursues justice in the outcome, and our legal society emphasizes that people must act within the scope of the rules.
We have discussed chivalry and the law before, so we will not elaborate here and go directly to the conclusion: chivalry must give way to legal rules. Because legal rules are the fundamental guarantee for the rights and interests of the vast majority of weak people in this world.
This is why I say that although Batman is "chivalrous", he must enter the squad room to step on the sewing machine.
We must accept that although justice exists, in real life, the law is actually a kind of flawed justice. This is an imperfection that a legal society must accept. As long as the imperfections and flaws are within the tolerance of justice, this imperfect justice can be accepted.
This is also the reason why some "justice will be delayed". We must admit that delayed justice is not justice at all, it is just a statement of facts. What we have to do is to accept this imperfect reality and at the same time, resolutely not advocate the poisonous chicken soup that "justice may be late, but it will never be absent."
Remember, people cannot achieve just goals through unjust means. Because means are seeds and justice is the tree. Seeds determine the type of tree, even if not all seeds grow into a tree
. . .
The book returns to its true story.
After that, Ye Feng and others went up to the next level. The fourth competition began, and the content of this competition was a game of Go. The competition format adopts round robin, which means that the competition will take a long time.
Ye Feng glanced at the moon outside. It was getting late and it had to end quickly.
So Ye Feng asked Butler Liu: "Senior Liu, can we change the rules of the competition? I'm in a hurry and I want it to end as soon as possible."
After all, the wives asked Ye Feng not to stay up all night
Butler Liu glanced at Ye Feng and smiled: "Yes, as long as everyone else agrees."
So Ye Feng looked at Zhao Qiansun and the others, cupped his hands, and said: "Everyone, since Senior Liu said yes, there is no problem with the process. Unfortunately, I am in a hurry, and this time the scholar's score will be counted towards the master. on the head, so”
Ye Feng paused deliberately, looked at Zhao Qiansun and the respective bookboys behind them, a total of six people, and said: "I will go down alone with six of you."
As soon as these words came out, the six people on the other side were shocked and stunned, but no laughter broke out after a moment. Because of the second temperament competition, Zhao, Qian, and Sun knew that Ye Feng was not an ordinary book boy, but a formidable opponent. However, I am not a freeloader, especially when it comes to playing chess. If you want to challenge six people, you're looking down on others.
Mr. Zhao said coldly: "What if you lose?"
Ye Feng said directly: "If I lose one of the six games, I will quit immediately."
"Okay!" Mr. Qian smiled, "It's a deal."
"It's a deal," Ye Feng said.
In fact, the three of them had just been thinking about how to exclude Ye Feng, the enemy's support, but they didn't expect that the other party would directly hit their guns. Then the three of them will naturally not miss this opportunity. That's why the three of them happily accepted the idea of bullying the few. After all, this was proposed by the other party.
As everyone knows, for Ye Feng, with one against six, I still have the advantage!
So the six chessboard tables were spaced apart at a certain distance and lined up one after another, with six people doing the work on one side of the chessboard.
But at this moment, something that made people feel heartbroken happened, because Hu San also sat across from him, and Ye Feng was already in a one-on-seven situation.
Ye Feng came to Hu San with a bit of a headache and said, "Let me tell you, I should be your book boy."
Hu San nodded and said: "Yes."
Ye Feng continued: "My grades should all be attributed to you."
Hu San nodded again and said: "Yes."
But your sister, damn!
Ye Feng said speechlessly again: "You and I should be in the same camp."
Hu San thought for a while, suddenly realized it, and said with a smile: "That's right!"
But just when everyone thought Hu San understood, they heard him say: "But I just want to have sex with you."
Hearing this, Ye Feng covered his eyes and didn't want to speak.
She didn't get it at all.
At the same time, Butler Liu covered his eyes and was speechless.
Zhao Qiansun and Shutong all cast sympathetic glances at Ye Feng.
Your master is truly the best.
