"Even if Liu Jing was desperate and called Liu Zhaodi for help, it is unlikely that Liu Zhaodi would agree to help without saying a word."
"But the fact is that Liu Zhaodi helped dispose of the body. Therefore, the person who called Liu Zhaodi and asked her to help was more likely to be Liu Yuanyuan. Liu Zhaodi may ignore Liu Jing, but he will not ignore Liu Yuanyuan's death. "
As Yang Feng's analysis continued to deepen, Wang Xing's spirit became more and more exciting: "Look, after analysis and analysis, the murderer is still Liu Yuanyuan."
"I only said that the person who called Liu Zhaodi to ask for help in disposing of the body was more likely to be Liu Yuanyuan. I did not say that Liu Yuanyuan must be the murderer."
"If Liu Jing killed someone, she thought that Liu Zhaodi might not be able to help dispose of the body because of her reputation, so she turned to Liu Yuanyuan for help, and finally Liu Yuanyuan spoke to Liu Zhaodi. This possibility also exists."
"In addition, Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing committed the crime together and killed He Shuangxi and Du Juan. In the end, Liu Yuanyuan asked Liu Zhaodi for help. This is also a possibility."
Then, Yang Feng changed the topic again:
"As I said just now, these three siblings are all masters of telling stories."
"In a criminal case, if you want to make your story appear to be consistent with the criminal facts, the most basic requirement is to use personal associations within the general framework composed of various objective factors when the criminal facts occurred."
"These objective factors include the location and time of the crime, details of the crime, tools for committing the crime, etc."
"This kind of half-truth and half-false confession formed by combining various objective factors may have the effect of confusing the public, distorting the facts, and even confusing the truth with the truth to achieve the purpose of replacing the real culprit."
"Obviously, the purpose of these three siblings is to compete to make themselves the real murderers."
"So, from their confessions, it is not difficult for us to see the existence of some objective elements or objective facts. For example, Du Juan and He Shuangxi died in the same order, and Du Juan's mobile phone was used to send text messages to Du Wen. These are all consistent with the objective facts .”
"The place where He Shuangxi died was in the living room of Liu Jing's home, and as long as Liu Jing's home has not changed the sofa or re-laid the floor, our police can extract relevant physical evidence from here. Although the comrades of the technical team have not yet given feedback , but I believe this should also be consistent with objective facts.”
"In addition, the three siblings also said that Du Juan was strangled to death. Although this cannot be verified with physical evidence for the time being, they are most likely to adhere to the principle of 'only replacing the real culprit' subconsciously, so this statement is also It's most likely true."
"The three siblings each used their imaginations to integrate themselves into the case and secretly replace the real culprit. In order to make themselves the murderer, there is no doubt that they need to grasp the full picture and all the details of the case."
"If it is not a joint crime, to achieve this, the three siblings must have shared and communicated about the incident, or it is also called 'information sharing."
"The problem lies in this 'information sharing.'"
"This goes back to my original question. Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing knew the details of He Shuangxi telling Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin to get out before he was killed, but Liu Zhaodi did not know about it."
After a pause, Yang Feng changed the topic again:
"For now, let's take a look at the confessions of the three siblings regarding the murder of He Shuangxi and Du Juan as a whole."
"Liu Zhaodi's confession showed that in addition to not knowing that He Shuangxi had told Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin to get out, it also showed that she was most likely not aware of the specific time when Liu Jing' was robbed, otherwise she would not have been so low-level at this point. The logical errors revealed that her confession was untrue."
"Based on this, I think Liu Zhaodi has the least comprehensive and detailed understanding of the deaths of He Shuangxi and Du Juan and related information. This is also consistent with our previous inference, that is, Liu Zhaodi is not suspected of committing the murder of these two people."
"Looking at Liu Yuanyuan's confession, she only knew that He Shuangxi hired two people to kill Liu Jing, but what were the names of these two people?
She couldn't tell her name or what she did. Liu Zhaodi didn't mention this at all, and she probably didn't know anything about it. "
"But what about Liu Jing? Not only did Liu Jing know that the two people He Shuangxi hired were named Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin, she also knew that they were construction workers."
"So, judging from the overall confessions given by the three siblings, Liu Jing has the most comprehensive grasp of the information, followed by Liu Yuanyuan, and Liu Zhaodi is the roughest."
"It is not difficult to see that in the process of information sharing, Liu Jing should be the source of information, Liu Yuanyuan should be the transfer station, and Liu Zhaodi should be the last one to obtain information."
"In the process of communication, they cannot copy and paste data and information, and then forward and receive them like computers, to achieve zero omission sharing of information resources, so it is inevitable that some details will be omitted. "
"Since Liu Jing is the source of information, he should be the real culprit who killed He Shuangxi and Du Juan. Moreover, he is the only one who knows the names and professions of the two killers hired by He Shuangxi. Based on this alone, he can be very responsible for the murders of He Shuangxi and Du Juan." His confession is largely believed to be true."
"According to what was said before, when these three siblings were making up stories, they most likely subconsciously adhered to the principle of 'only substituting the real culprit' and would not deliberately distort or conceal known objective facts. Liu Yuanyuan relied on the objective facts she knew In fact, he integrated himself and wanted to take the blame for Liu Jing, but he obviously didn't know the relevant situation of the two killers.
"Based on this, we can rule out the possibility that Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing jointly committed the murder of He Shuangxi and Du Juan."
"So, there is only one real culprit who killed these two people, and that was Liu Jing. After he killed the person, he called Liu Yuanyuan, and Liu Yuanyuan asked Liu Zhaodi for help and asked her to help dispose of the body."
"During this process, there were omissions in Liu Jing's crime process and the transmission of relevant information, which resulted in the situation we are seeing now. The crime process described by the three siblings was roughly the same, but some details were slightly different. Differences."
"Of course, it is these inconspicuous nuances that reveal who the real culprit is."
Then, Yang Feng looked at Wang Xing again: "As for the day you said that He Shuangxi was killed, Liu Zhaodi claimed that she gave Liu Jing four scenic spot tickets and asked him to take the old lady and two children out. Liu Yuanyuan's confession also confirmed this Got this."
"Why are the confessions of Liu Zhaodi and Liu Yuanyuan consistent? It's very simple. They both told lies, and they should have colluded in confession beforehand. It's just that the purpose of the collusion was not consistent. I have said this before. "
"It's not impossible for Liu Jing to say that he doesn't remember where the whole family went that day."
"For him, he just needs to make sure that he is the only one at home that day. As for whether he found some excuse to send the old lady and the child out that day, or it happened that the two children really had something to go out for, such as going to the hospital with a cold or fever. Well, among the seven aunts and eight aunts, who has a wedding or wedding, or what kind of activities are held at the child’s school, I might not remember it.”
Wang Xing did not refute.
Wu Xiaojun looked at the three confessions in front of him:
"I agree with Captain Yang's opinion. The suspect who killed Du Juan and He Shuangxi has basically been identified as Liu Jing... But what about the two Yuan brothers? The confessions of the three siblings about the murder of the two Yuan brothers are basically the same. I'm afraid it will be difficult. Find logical loopholes in their confessions to determine who the real culprit is."
This time Wang Xing thought about it seriously, and then said: "Such highly similar confessions can only mean one thing. The three of them are accomplices and participated in the murder of the two Yuan brothers."
"Besides, Captain Yang also said before that every one of the three Liu siblings must have taken a life, so they rushed to admit that he killed these four people alone. This way, one can save two."
"From the current point of view, Liu Yuanyuan carried the life of Zhou Xiaolu, Liu Jing carried the lives of Du Juan and He Shuangxi, and Liu Zhaodi, as an accomplice, also carried the lives of the two Yuan brothers. Only in this way can it be consistent with the inference. "
Although Yang Feng did not
He expressed different opinions on this, but he did not make any judgment on this: "The death of the two brothers of the Yuan family can only be started from their bodies, as well as the pig pen where the third brother and sister of the Liu family said they were imprisoned, the autopsy report and the crime scene The survey report won’t be available for a while, so we’ll have to wait.”
Then, Yang Feng remembered another thing:
"Liu Yuanyuan's confession about the murder of Zhou Xiaolu must also be verified. Let someone ask Shang Biao. In the days before and after Zhou Xiaolu's death, that is, from July 1 to July 5, 2004, he went I went out of town to stay with Liu Yuanyuan, who was studying for graduate school. During this period, did Liu Yuanyuan suddenly leave for a day or two? We also need to write to the local police and ask someone to visit Liu Yuanyuan’s mentor to verify.”
After a pause, Yang Feng muttered to himself: "I called Liu Yuanyuan back then and asked if Shang Biao was with her during that time. She said yes, and she also said that she would die badly if she lied... ...Hmph, of course she didn't lie. I asked the wrong question. I should have asked her about her specific itinerary... Damn it."
Finally, Yang Feng couldn't help but yawned: "Let's call it a day and let the three siblings go back to their single rooms... wait until the physical evidence report comes out tomorrow."
Wu Xiaojun also stretched while packing up the materials and preparing to leave.
However, Wang Xing still sat motionless on the stool, looking extremely lost in thought.
In the extremely puzzled eyes of Yang Feng and Wu Xiaojun, Wang Xing suddenly said: "Captain Yang...if Liu Jing killed Du Juan, he would be able to do it in the face of my door-to-door interrogation in just a few days." There's something wrong with the calm expression and calm heart."
