When her daughter Tiantian saw the scars on her mother's body, she cried bitterly. This caused Liu Yuanyuan's resentment and anger to completely explode. She decided not to be the "Silence of the Lambs" and instead determined to get rid of the Yuan brothers.
This time, Liu Yuanyuan did not intend to let the two brothers die too happily. In her eyes, the two Yuan brothers were just two well-dressed beasts, and she had to pay back double the humiliation she had suffered from them.
It happened that Liu Zhaodi called her again and told her that the old lady was going to Liu Jing's house to help take care of the children recently, and asked her to take Tiantianduo to see the old lady when she had time.
Therefore, Liu Yuanyuan decided to subdue the two Yuan brothers with sleeping pills at the old lady's house in the countryside, and then let them suffer humiliation before they died.
For Liu Yuanyuan, it was easy and no difficulty to lure the two Yuan brothers to their hometown in the countryside.
The excuse she used to deceive the two Yuan brothers was basically the same as the excuses Liu Zhaodi and Liu Jing used in their respective statements. In her final statement, she also claimed that she had abused them with a belt and a rake, but in the end she beat them to death with a brick.
Yang Feng read back and forth the three confessions given by the three siblings of the Liu family in the conference room, trying to find logical loopholes in them to determine the authenticity of the three confessions.
Wang Xing looked at the three confessions in front of him, and after answering a phone call, he began to express his opinions:
"Three years ago, Liu Zhaodi claimed that she gave Liu Jing four scenic spot tickets and asked him to take the old lady and two children out. Liu Yuanyuan's confession also confirmed this."
"However, Liu Jing's confession not only did not mention this, but was also vague about the whereabouts of the two children that day. She also said that she killed He Shuangxi with an iron rod at home."
"I originally thought I could ask the old lady and two children of the Liu family to verify whether Liu Jing went out with her whole family that day. But so much time has passed, and all of them, old and young, have come to ask questions. Our people said they don't remember."
The call Wang Xing received just now was the feedback from other case investigators on this point.
"In any case, this part of Liu Yuanyuan's and Liu Zhaodi's confession is consistent and contradicts this part of Liu Jing's confession."
"Contradictions, one true and one false."
"Regardless of who the real culprit was who killed He Shuangxi, just judging from whether Liu Zhaodi gave Liu Jing 4 tickets on this day three years ago, we can compare this part of Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Zhaodi The oral confession is regarded as one proposition, and the confession that Liu Jing denied this is regarded as another proposition."
"There is a contradiction between these two propositions. One of them must be true and the other must be false."
"Which one is true and which one is false? Let's put this issue aside for now and then look at the possibility of these three siblings colluding in the confession."
"Collusive confessions usually refer to the behavior of the illegal actors, as well as the illegal actors and other relevant persons in the case, who use a unified voice, establish an offensive and defensive alliance, and distort the facts of the crime in order to achieve the purpose of allowing the illegal actors to evade legal responsibility. "
"But there are obviously many inconsistencies in the confessions of these three siblings, and this is just one of them. In other words, it is unlikely that they colluded in confessing in advance."
"Without any collusion in confession in advance, these parts of the confessions of Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Zhaodi are unanimously consistent, so they can be regarded as true, while Liu Jing's confession is contrary to falsehood."
"In other words, Liu Jing did not kill He Shuangxi. The real culprits who killed He Shuangxi should be Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Zhaodi."
Yang Feng nodded, seeming to agree with this, but then shook his head, seeming to disagree.
Wang Xing was confused: "Captain Yang, what do you mean by this? Do you approve or disapprove?"
"I'm thinking that these three siblings actually know many details about the murder of these four victims...especially the details involving some key evidence."
"For example, they used Du Juan's cell phone to send a message to Du Wen; when they killed He Shuangxi, they said he was beaten to death with an iron rod at Liu Jing's house; the bodies of He Shuangxi and Du Juan were sent to the funeral parlor for cremation; Before killing the two Yuan brothers, they both humiliated and abused them."
"These details, our police
Both parties were able to find or extract relevant physical evidence based on this. They all knew that they could not falsify this, so they all chose to give truthful feedback. Therefore, the confessions in these aspects were basically consistent. "
"They all know these key details. What does it mean? It means that the death of these four people was at least communicated between the three siblings. In other words, all three of them were involved in the death of these four people, or... The murder of some of these four people."
"Whether there has been communication or joint participation, under such a premise, in order to avoid responsibility after the incident is revealed, is it natural and easy to conspire and confess in advance to resist the police investigation?"
"Just from the confessions of these three siblings, we can tell that they are all masters of telling stories. If they want to collude in confession, it should not be impossible for them."
Then, Yang Feng looked at Wang Xing: "The reason why you think there is no collusion between them is mainly because their confessions are basically consistent and even contradictory."
"But you have overlooked one point. They are not trying to avoid culpability for themselves. On the contrary, they are rushing to take over everything. They want to bear all the culpability alone, so as to clear the suspicion of the other two people. In this way, , it is inevitable that there will be contradictions between each other’s confessions.”
"So, I think it's not that there was no collusion among the three siblings, but that there was no agreement on the purpose of the collusion. In other words, they probably didn't agree on who should bear all the blame, and they all wanted to sacrifice Protect others by yourself.”
"In this way, a situation arises where you say what you say and I say what I say mine. As for the final result... well, none of them can control that much anymore. Let us, the police, make the judgment."
"Since they all have such thoughts, what can it mean?"
"It shows that none of these three siblings are innocent. Each of them has carried a human life, so whether it is for each of them or for the other two, no matter who the real murderer is finally identified by the police, they All three can accept it.”
"Besides, breaking one is definitely better than breaking three."
As he spoke, Yang Feng couldn't help but cursed "Chinese quintessence", and then continued:
"Do your best and obey fate. If you are not a family, you will not belong to the same family. These three siblings are indeed born from the same mother. They all want to do their best to save the other two. As for the final result... it depends on fate."
"If there is destiny, then why do we need the law? What do we need to do?"
"You clown, you are so smart, you think that if you do this, our police will not be able to find out the real culprit who killed those four people one by one? Do you really think that we are all just doing food?"
Then, Yang Feng turned his attention to Wang Xing: "You took the selection test for the provincial department some time ago and did those messy "Xingzhi" test questions, which made your brain stupid, right? Are there true and false propositions, contradictory and contradictory? This guy is handling a damn case, not doing logical reasoning questions, don't do that 'paper talk' thing."
Wang Xing laughed a few times.
"We still have to be as realistic as possible and speak based on the existing confessions and evidence."
As Yang Feng spoke, he opened Liu Zhaodi's confession and pointed to one of the passages:.
"When Liu Zhaodi said that she was hesitating, Liu Jing suddenly called and said that he was robbed last night. Fortunately, there was no danger. After learning about this situation, Liu Zhaodi thought that Liu Jing would not be there in a short time. What danger was there, so I made up my mind and strangled Du Juan to death with a rope, and that night, I used Du Juan’s cell phone to send the text message to Du Wen.”
"If I remember correctly, you said that when you were investigating Du Juan's disappearance, it was January 24, 2016. This day was ***'s fiftieth birthday. Du Wen received this text message from Du Juan that night, so he found you Demand that the case be withdrawn.”
"According to the above-mentioned confession of Liu Zhaodi, Liu Jing said on the phone, 'He was robbed last night. The time Liu Jing refers to here should be the night of the 23rd. In other words, what was revealed in this section of Liu Zhaodi's confession
The information that came out means that the last time Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin made a desperate move and directly used their axes to kill Liu Jing face to face was on the night of the 23rd. "
"But in Tao Qiangsheng's confession, although Tao Qiangsheng did not remember the specific date of the last murder of He Shuangxi, he revealed a very important information, that is, after the murder of Liu Jing failed again that day, as soon as he returned to the rental He killed Tao Lixin and immediately called He Shuangxi for help and threw Tao Lixin's body into the cave in Zhuxi Village."
"After all this was dealt with, Tao Qiangsheng took the money and left, and had no further contact with He Shuangxi."
"We previously investigated the call records of He Shuangxi's mobile phone number, which showed that from the early morning of the 25th, there was indeed no call record between Tao Qiangsheng and He Shuangxi. During the day of the 25th, He Shuangxi drove his private car into the repair shop. , thus leaving a record of the time of registration at the factory."
"This shows that Tao Qiangsheng took the money and left in the early morning of the 25th. The last call record between him and He Shuangxi in the early morning of the 25th should be that he called He Shuangxi to help dispose of Tao Lixin's body."
"Based on this, the last murder of Liu Jing by Tao Qiangsheng and Tao Lixin should have been on the night of the 24th, not the night of the 23rd."
"So, this part of Liu Zhaodi's confession is untrue, and her confession that she killed He Shuangxi and Du Juan is also not credible. The real culprits who killed these two people should be Liu Yuanyuan and Liu Jing."
