Regarding the issue of Yang Xuangan's rebellion, several book friends chatted with me privately and kept saying that the Yang family and his son had the intention to rebel as early as the Yang Su period. Their views and arguments were roughly "Mr. Meng Xman said so." , don’t you think it’s wrong?”
Later, I specifically read the works written by that teacher, and came to the conclusion that she was also a writer and writer, not a historian at all. Apart from anything else, there was something very wrong with Yang Xuangan's rebellion. The reason was that she had always placed the responsibility for Yang Xuangan's rebellion on Yang Su, saying that the Yang family had prepared to rebel as early as Yang Su's period.
And her most powerful and sharpest argument is what Yang Su said when he and his wife were arguing, "If I were the emperor, you would never want to be the queen." Then based on this sentence, she wrote in a book that "it is very taboo in the feudal dynasty." As a top figure in the Sui Dynasty, it is only reasonable that Yang Su should be cautious about these things. If he had no evil intentions, how could he say such things? And the fact that he blurted it out during the quarrel just shows that this is something deep in Yang Su's heart. my true thoughts.”
This so-called sharpest argument is actually a very irresponsible attitude: First of all, the Sui and Tang Dynasties were open-minded. When the army returned from victory, there were many soldiers and civilians shouting "Long live XX", with names like "Long live", "Dragon and Phoenix". "There are many people. So when Yang Su and his wife were quarreling behind closed doors, he said angrily to his wife, "If I were the emperor, you would never be the queen." In fact, it was a private quarrel between the couple, but Yang Su never thought of it in his dreams. , such an ordinary stumble, was regarded by his wife as evidence of his own death, and based on this, he told the emperor and empress that Yang Su was plotting evil and preparing to rebel.
If it were an ordinary family, then the quarrel would be over. It's just that Yang Su is a person above ten thousand people and his reputation in history is not very good, so his inappropriate remarks were naturally amplified infinitely.
And what was Yang Jian's reaction at that time? Yang Jian only suspended Yang Su from his post for a period of time, and soon after, he reinstated Yang Su. Personally, I think this matter caused a big fuss, so Yang Jian suspended him from his post to explain to the people of the world. This is just a matter of attitude. Otherwise, how could the wise and mighty Yang Jian reinstate Yang Suguan to his post in such a short period of time?
Secondly, before Yang Su died, the Great Sui Dynasty was prosperous and prosperous, and the country was peaceful and the people were peaceful. No matter how powerful Yang Su was, he would not think of dying in the third generation of the Great Sui Dynasty, right? Therefore, it is really unreliable to say that he was preparing to rebel during the Yang Jian era.
After taking a closer look at this teacher's works, I found that she actually translated, excerpted, and borrowed from the works of many historians. Then she took a piece here, cut a piece there, and then modified it with a ridiculing tone and humorous writing style, which made people feel There is no trace of other historians, and it is finally sewn into a "history book" that looks like a hundred-fold garment.
This type of prosperous "historians" are actually very similar to the "beautiful writers" of more than ten or twenty years ago.
The content of physical books written by "beautiful writers" is almost the same: the first step is to classify the styles of poems, then select them and put them together;
The second step is to attach the translation and appreciation content of famous writers from past dynasties;
The third step is to introduce the poet’s life experience and the creative background of the poem;
The fourth step is to combine the previous content, incorporate your own feelings and insights, and write an article or paragraph of reflections after reading;
The fifth step is to write a summary of the emotional experiences, similarities, differences, and own insights of the two or three poets, thus forming a section of a book.
These chapters and sections add up to form an "authoritative book" and "best-seller" that is deeply loved by college students.
After writing the graceful genre, I then wrote about the bold, frontier, military, resentful women, and brothel genres... In this way, after writing each book, I piled up "beautiful writers" who are knowledgeable and well-informed.
The most famous among them is undoubtedly An Xru. And the current teacher Meng Xman is actually An Xru from back then. But when it comes to the beauty of writing, it is really far inferior to An Xru.
Brothers, if you really want to understand history, it is best to read the works of officially certified historians. Although the works of these historians may seem obscure, boring, cold, and boring to read, their credibility is more than a hundred times stronger.
——My personal opinion, please don’t criticize if inappropriate!
