The premiere of "Changjin Lake: Shuimen Bridge" has ended.
The reactions of the audience in the theater varied. Some had red eyes, and it was obvious that they had cried. Some frowned, as if they were not satisfied with the movie, and some were silent and sighing.
This is a normal situation. It is impossible for everyone to like a movie. No matter how good the movie is, people may not like it or not.
Not to mention epic war blockbusters like "Changjin Lake: Suimen Bridge".
After all, this type of movie is adapted from history that actually happened, so it can be said that this kind of movie is the most difficult to get unanimous approval.
Why?
Because with a movie like this, you can't really be flawless.
For example, many tactics, no matter how the movie unfolds, people will criticize them.
So after the premiere of "Changjin Lake: Shuimen Bridge", the audience's evaluation was somewhat similar to the earlier first "Changjin Lake".
There are definitely many positive reviews.
"Seven companies were interspersed to respond to a hundred and fifty-seven people. In fact, there was only one person. Looking at the back of the solitary figure five thousand miles away, he burst into tears!"
"Tan Ziwei was injured a long time ago, but he endured it and didn't let everyone know. The movie only briefly describes that kind of pain, but watching it was heart-wrenching. The hero who couldn't be beaten died with his blood drained. How strong I am. Volunteer soldiers!”
"The ending report: 157 people from the Seventh Company were expected, but only one person actually arrived! Many people may not have noticed that no one from the Nineth Company reported it, and none of the Nineth Company survived... And this is only a small part of what the movie can show. It can be imagined that You know how much the volunteer soldiers paid back then!"
"War is really cruel. Human life is nothing in front of bullet tanks. Although it is just a movie, it takes us to understand the history, tells us the cruelty and ruthlessness of war, and lets us know that life now is hard-won. Some movies It’s not just a movie, it will touch your heart and brain hard, imprint it into your soul, and then slowly but endlessly trigger your aftertaste and thinking, and even change you!”
"My heart has never let go after three bridge bombings. We are still like this, so what kind of suffering did the volunteer soldiers who stood on the front line experience? We live in the future they extravagantly hoped for, and the patriotic feelings that arise naturally are better than those in the previous works. It’s more intense and sincere. Who are we qualified to comment on now? We can only say that the battlefield is cruel, remember the martyrs and pay tribute to the heroes!”
"This war has been fought by one generation and suffered by five generations."
"The growth line of Wu Wanli is really heartbreaking. The war not only makes a young man mature quickly, but also makes him age quickly."
"There are no heroes who can't freeze to death, let alone those who can't be killed. There is only the glory of soldiers. But I really didn't expect that in the end, Tan Ziwei's death was so "peaceful". He was talking to the soldiers. He died silently in the process, because he had already been shot in the abdomen and his blood had dried up. Perhaps more volunteer soldiers died in such a "plain" way, aren't they considered heroes?"
"I noticed a detail. After the second bombing of the bridge, several of the remaining soldiers from the Seventh and Ninth Companies fell asleep forever. This detail is really thoughtful, because historically, the Volunteer Army fought hard after the Battle of Changjin Lake. Among them, more than 4,000 people froze to death. They did not die under the enemy's artillery fire, but died in the ice and snow."
"The bombing of the bridge is actually very detailed. I have read interviews with people who have witnessed it. Historically, to blow up the Watergate Bridge, the junction between the bridge head and the road must be blown up. This is also shown in the film."
"I think the most tragic sacrifice in the whole movie is not Wu Qianli and Mei Sheng, but Yu Congrong who was supposed to stay behind. He actually could have survived, but he still pulled the trigger and chose to sacrifice himself to save the company. Watching Yu Congrong still keep running in the sea of fire until he turned into ashes, I cried to death!"
Of course, apart from these positive reviews, there are also some critical negative reviews.
"After watching this movie, I felt that the sacrifice of the soldiers of the Seventh Company was very ritualistic. The sacrifices of other soldiers were just brushed off. Isn't it too personal heroism?"
"The three bombings of the Watergate Bridge in history are not like this at all, right? Since it is adapted from a real historical battle, it cannot be made up, right? There is also a high point behind the Watergate Bridge defenders that the US defenders did not occupy, allowing our army to And attack from behind again and again?"
"It used to be an anti-Japanese drama, but now it's an anti-American drama. It feels like there's no difference at all. It makes the enemy mentally retarded. The US military is almost defeated and yet it's still so arrogant? Is it possible? Still want to capture prisoners? Don't you know that Wu Qianli is here? The one who blew up the bridge?”
"As a military fan, I was really speechless after watching this movie. Pinghe and another soldier from the 7th Company rushed the tank, but they all rushed from the front. Everyone should know that tanks are not actually flexible. The sides are the blind spots for tanks to attack. I don’t understand why a soldier who is a veteran of many battles doesn’t understand this? Why should he rush towards the tank from the front?”
"The first explosive package only created a crater, but the second explosive package overturned the tank and destroyed the Watergate Bridge. How can the power of the same explosive package be so different?"
"Shouldn't the bridge piers be blown up when a bridge is blown up? Why would that place be blown up? For such a big bug, it is said that the movie even hired military experts as consultants. What kind of amateur consultants are they?"
As a result, the ratings of "Changjin Lake: Shuimen Bridge" on the popular film review website are naturally predictable.
After the premiere and in the early morning of October 1, the rating of "Changjin Lake: Shuimen Bridge" was only 7.8.
Although there are many middle-aged people who give high scores, there are also many who only give the lowest scores.
In the film review area, there are also polarizations. Some people think the movie is very good, but other people have all kinds of faults.
However, this does not prevent the popularity of "Changjin Lake: Shuimen Bridge".
On the day of its premiere on September 30, although it could only be regarded as an early screening and there were not many screenings, it still had a box office of over 100 million.
And soon, many fans responded to those critical comments.
"Blow up bridges and piers? Ignorance is not your fault. Show off your ignorance and find fault. I'm really speechless. Let's find out what the Watergate Bridge is and read the real historical materials before talking about it. Qiaotou The junction with the highway is where the three-bombing Watergate Bridge exploded!"
"That netizen who claims to be a military fan, are you really a military fan? I'm confused. Didn't you understand the scene? Everyone knows that the side of a tank is safer than the front, but do Pinghe and the others have any choice? Once the heavy tank is launched Come here, then do they still have a chance to blow up the bridge? There is simply no way to do it, and the side is already blocked there. If you don't rush towards that side, go to the side? "
"The first time the explosive package exploded because it was too far away. In addition, the location of the explosion was not actually the bridge deck at all, but the road in front of the bridge. It is normal to explode a crater, right? The second time Pinghe was at a designated location. The connection between the bridge deck and the road exploded under the tank again, can it be the same?"
"It makes me happy to say that the sacrifice of soldiers from the Seventh Company is ritualistic, while the sacrifice of other soldiers is unknown. This is a movie. According to you, don't make a movie. Even documentaries have the perspective of the protagonist, let alone a movie. Got it!"
