The reason why the school approved the live broadcast of this debate competition in the first grade of high school is because the result is within the school's control.
"Should the class teacher be serious about students being late?" 》In this debate question, the concepts of right and wrong and values are clear at a glance. Do you still need to ask? Of course it's time.
The winner is definitely the right side.
But, you have to argue.
Why do you still have to argue?
For some things that students should do, it is useless for the class teacher to say them. The students have to say them in their own words to generate internal drive to be effective.
Of course, taking the opportunity to exercise students' critical thinking and eloquence is also one of the purposes.
The topic must not be said to be late, but the essence must be seen through the phenomenon.
It is also a commonplace debate topic, which is nothing more than the issue of commonality and individuality in education. The affirmative's foothold is commonality, while the negative side looks for a breakthrough from individuality.
The arguments and arguments for the common features of Zhengfang education are easy to find, and they can be summarized in three main points.
1. Without rules, there is no circle. Only with awe can you know how to behave;
2. Details determine success or failure;
3. If you don’t sweep one house, how can you sweep the world?
The arguments against educating individuality focus on the constraints of rules on individuality. For example the following.
1. Roses bloom in the sun precisely because they have thorns;
2. People are born equal, but they are born with different personalities;
3. Some truly valuable things are probably things that you can’t stand and have a personal touch.
Gong Zifeng concluded the fourth argument of the opposing side. He pointed out that the essence of teaching students in accordance with their aptitude is to meet individual needs. The essence of the head teacher being serious about individual students being late is to obliterate the individual needs of individual students.
The most direct example he cited was Octavia.
Senior Xing Rui is the only provincial champion in Aicheng so far. During his high school days, he didn't even attend classes, let alone being late.
His last words were to Xu Cheng.
"Teacher Xu, if you were more serious back then and forced Senior Octavia to sit in class and he was suspended after being late three times a week, do you think Senior Octavia would have become the only provincial champion in Acropolis? That's my final argument. Thank you all. ."
I have to say that Gong Zifeng was well prepared for this debate and his performance was really outstanding.
There are seven judges in the debate, four are student judges, who are among the top 10 outstanding seniors in the top class of this year's senior year, and the other three judges are highly prestigious Chinese teachers at Aicheng Middle School.
After the judges’ comments and scores, the positive side won with a score of four to three.
However, given the difficulty of the topic itself, it would be an honor for the opposing side to lose.
Through the debate, Gong Zifeng received everyone's attention and recognition, and his self-confidence greatly increased. However, he was still a little dissatisfied.
He felt that his last question about Xu Cheng was correct.
The debate lasted for two hours, and there was no urination during the whole process. The students watching the live broadcast listened with gusto.
At the end of the debate, Xu Cheng took the stage.
"What classmate Gong Zifeng asked me, as an educator, I can't answer. History cannot be assumed, and an educator is not allowed to experiment with a child. The reality is that Octavia became the first provincial champion in Acropolis and the only one so far."
"Gong Zifeng, I think it might be more appropriate for your senior Octavia to answer this question for you personally. Next, I would like to invite Octavia, a former outstanding student of Aicheng Middle School, to give you the concluding remarks."
When Octavia walked into Class 20, the students and judges present were shocked, and then the classroom burst into warm applause.
Other classes watching the live broadcast also couldn't help but applaud.
Among the crowd, Gong Zifeng clapped the most vigorously, his eyes shining with excitement.
Octavia has a good image and temperament, is mature and stable, and has the aura of being the provincial champion. Standing among a group of sixteen or seventeen-year-old teenagers, he is like a star among the stars.
He fulfills all the students' fantasies about being the provincial champion, and his words and deeds will really affect this group of children.
He said the following about the argument.
"Arrived in the debate is the rule, late is broken, late is broken. I personally believe that the fate of rules is to be broken."
As soon as these words came out, the opposition supporters headed by Gong Zifeng looked at each other with excitement and pride.
"But what happens after it is broken? It must be established. Breaking is never the goal. Rebuilding better and better rules after breaking is the goal of breaking."
"Destruction and cubes are the basis for action. Destruction without establishment will inevitably lead to disorder and chaos. World disorder will lead to war, national disorder will lead to chaos, and school disorder will be a disaster for education."
He set his sights on Gong Zifeng, which was meaningful.
"Senior, please think about the following questions before you think about breaking the rules:
1. Is the lateness rule that I want to break now a vicious rule?
2. Based on individual needs, you can break the rules that are beneficial to the public. After breaking them, can you establish rules that are more beneficial to your own needs than the public rules?
3. Is your breaking just for the sake of breaking and not having any relationship at all?
What I can tell you is that Teacher Xu Cheng respected my opinions and did not force me to sit in class like other students. It was not because I broke the rules, but because he saw that I had established my own rules and followed them. efficient.
I hope my words can arouse everyone's thinking, thank you. "
That’s all Mingrui said.
Thunderous applause sounded again, and the Octavia gentleman left the stage.
The debate ended successfully.
When Xu Cheng sent Mingrui out of the classroom, he accidentally saw Gong Zifeng looking at Mingrui with admiration and yearning. His thoughts changed, and before leaving the classroom, he waved to him, "Gong Zifeng, come with the teacher."
When Gong Zifeng heard this, his face was filled with surprise, and his eyes were shining like stars.
He followed them eagerly, nervous and excited.
When he reached the stairs, Octavia turned around, raised his hand to rub his head, and smiled gently, "Little brother, come on."
Gong Zifeng's face turned red and he boldly spoke:
"Ming, senior Mingrui, can you sign your name for me?"
"sure."
Xu Cheng handed Mingrui a gel pen and he looked at Gong Zifeng. For a moment, he didn't know where to sign.
Just as he was about to ask him to go back and get a notebook, Gong Zifeng suddenly turned around and turned his back to him, "Senior Octavia, sign this and sign it on my school uniform."
Octavia chuckled lightly and wrote the four characters "Future is promising" on the back of his school uniform, followed by his name in small fonts.
After signing, Xu Cheng said to Gong Zifeng: "You performed well today, let's go back."
Gong Zifeng was happy from the inside out, bowed to Xu Cheng, glanced at Octavia reluctantly, turned around, paused, and ran back to the classroom.
On Wednesday, Octavia and Xu Zhiyi returned to Hangzhou.
Early Thursday morning, investigators from the Shanghai headquarters went to the Hangcheng branch to investigate Octavia.
During the investigation, Octavia was temporarily unable to exercise leadership decision-making power, and the company could not be leaderless. Management power was temporarily exercised by Li Zezhong.
After being questioned by investigators from the Shanghai headquarters, Octavia walked out of the investigation room and met Li Zezhong at the elevator entrance.
Obviously, this was no accident. Li Zezhong was waiting for him intentionally, and he couldn't hide his pride.
